0.2269
7667766266
x

Tagore’s Cosmopolitan Nationalism

iasparliament Logo
May 08, 2025

Mains Syllabus: GS I - Indian Heritage , Culture, History and Society. Modern Indian history from about the middle of the eighteenth century until the present- significant events, personalities, issues. The Freedom Struggle — its various stages and important contributors/contributions from different parts of the country.

Why in the News?

Rabindranath Tagore Jayanti is celebrated on May 7.

What is the view of Tagore on Nationalism?

  • Tagore on Nationalism – Rabindranath Tagore's concept of nationalism was critical of aggressive, narrow nationalism, particularly the Western model that emphasized territoriality and competition.
  • Tagore’s essays, especially in his book Nationalism (1917), present his thoughts on how nationalism, particularly Western-style nationalism, could be dangerous.
  • In it, he criticizes the way nationalism was practiced and argues for a society built on cooperation and universal values rather than competition and aggression.
  • Rejection of Aggressive Nationalism -Tagore viewed narrow nationalism, which prioritizes a nation's territorial boundaries and power, as divisive and prone to conflict.
  • He believed it neglected fundamental human values and hindered genuine societal progress.
  • In his remarkable work Ghare Baire, or The Home and the World, Tagore expressed apprehension over the anticolonial response to the British leading to Hindus and Muslims rigidly defining their identities.
  • Advocacy for Cosmopolitanism - Tagore championed a cosmopolitan perspective, emphasizing the interconnectedness of all humanity and the importance of cultural exchange and cooperation.
  • He envisioned a world where individuals saw themselves as part of a global community, transcending parochial loyalties.
  • Focus on Humanity and Spirituality - Tagore emphasized the importance of spiritual unity and understanding between individuals, guided by love, respect, and mutual trust.
  • Emphasis on Indian Culture and Traditions - While critical of Western-style nationalism, Tagore also valued Indian culture, traditions, and humanity, promoting a more inclusive and spiritual understanding of nationalism.

What are the different types of nationalism advocated by Tagore?

  • Cultural Nationalism - Tagore emphasized the importance of preserving Indian culture, traditions, and heritage.
  • Spiritual Nationalism - He believed in the spiritual unity of India, transcending religious and regional divisions.
  • Humanistic Nationalism - Tagore prioritized human values, such as love, compassion, and equality, over narrow nationalistic interests.
  • Anti-Colonial Nationalism - He opposed British colonial rule, advocating for Indian independence and self-rule.
  • Internationalism - Tagore envisioned a global community, where nations coexisted in harmony, sharing knowledge and culture.

What is the comparison between Gandhi and Tagore on Nationalism ?

Difference Between Gandhi and Tagore on Nationalism

Rabindranath Tagore

Mahatma Gandhi

Tagore believed in more inclusive and spiritual nationalism, emphasizing the importance of Indian culture and traditions

Gandhi's nationalism was rooted in politics and the struggle for Indian independence.

For Rabindranath Tagore, the view of nationalism and patriotism that the movement was taking on was

too narrow.

Gandhi saw nationalism as a means to achieve Indian independence and self-rule.

Tagore envisioned a global community.

Gandhi advocated for Indian self-sufficiency and isolation from Western influences.

Similarities on Nationalism

Humanistic Nationalism

  • Both Gandhi and Tagore believed in a form of nationalism rooted in respect for all humanity.
  • They argued that love for one’s country should not breed hatred or contempt for others.
  • Gandhi’s idea of Sarvodaya (welfare of all) and Tagore’s advocacy for universal brotherhood reflected their shared view that nations should uplift humanity, not divide it

Cultural and Spiritual Identity Over Political Identity

  •  For both thinkers, the soul of a nation was not its political or military power but its cultural and spiritual values.
  • Gandhi’s emphasis on Swaraj (self-rule) was not just political independence but also moral and cultural self-reliance.
  • Similarly, Tagore valued India’s cultural heritage and believed it could enrich the world, emphasizing that true freedom comes from within.

Non-violence and Ethical Means of Resistance

  • Gandhi and Tagore both rejected aggressive or violent forms of nationalism.
  • Gandhi’s philosophy of Ahimsa (non-violence) was integral to his vision for a free India, while Tagore argued that nationalism rooted in aggression and hatred was harmful.
  • Both believed that a just and lasting independence must come through ethical means and mutual respect.

Nationalism Beyond Materialism

  • Gandhi and Tagore were both wary of a nationalism driven by materialism or economic exploitation.
  • They advocated for a sustainable, self-sufficient society where people’s needs were met without excessive consumption.
  • Gandhi’s Swadeshi movement encouraged local production and self-sufficiency, while Tagore promoted a simple, sustainable life that respected natural resources.

Conclusion

  • In essence, Tagore's concept of nationalism was not an outright rejection of patriotism but a call for a more humane and spiritual understanding of national identity, one that prioritized universal values and global cooperation over narrow self-interest and territorial competition.

Reference

The Indian Express | Tagore

 

Login or Register to Post Comments
There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to review.

ARCHIVES

MONTH/YEARWISE ARCHIVES

sidetext
Free UPSC Interview Guidance Programme
sidetext