Supreme Court Verdict on Aadhaar - II

Click here for Part I

Why in news?

The Supreme Court recently delivered its decision on the constitutionality of the Aadhaar unique identification system.

What is the Court's rationale?

• The failure to establish the identity of an individual is a major hindrance to the successful implementation of welfare programmes.
• Absence of a credible system to authenticate identity made it difficult for subsidies/benefits/services to reach the intended beneficiaries.

• The Aadhaar project thus ensures dignity for marginalised sections along with services, benefits and subsidies by leveraging the power of technology.
• The use of Aadhaar had also increased over time.
• The enrolment reached 1.2 billion people, and the programme had acquired a scale and momentum that is irreversible.
• Necessary measures were also taken to ensure security of information provided by individuals while enrolling.
• So the Court upheld the constitutional validity of Aadhaar and clarified areas in which it cannot be made mandatory.
• The judgement has thus plugged the loopholes rather than strike down the project altogether.

What next?

• There will be concerns with implementation as many businesses are likely to be affected adversely with the decision.
• Also, with respect to access to welfare schemes, it is possible that questions of exclusion and discrimination may be raised again.
• It is now for the government to focus on the implementation of this ruling.
• It must ensure that all such excessive demands are stopped, or it will be in contempt of court.
• The government has in the past, with impunity, extended the use of Aadhaar in defiance of previous Supreme Court stays on such actions.
• So the Supreme Court, too, must follow up on its judgment.

Source: The Hindu, Business Standard