What is the issue?
- Hindu rightwing groups tend to portray rationalism as a western concept which is alien to Indian ethos and way of life.
- But a look at India’s deep rooted philosophical tradition reveals that there has been a vibrant spirit of rationalist throughout.
How has the rationalist tradition shaped up in India?
- It is believed that faith rules in India and that the number of Indians who didn’t state their religion was only 3 million in the 2011 census.
- Nonetheless, this is a massive increase from the 2001 census where just about 700,000 had not declared a religion.
Ancient India:
- Rationalists and sceptics who held out for scientific ideas have been a part of the Indian tradition since at least the 6th century BC.
- “Ajita Kesakambalin”, a contemporary of the Buddha, was the earliest known teacher of complete materialism (stripped of any spiritual pursuit in life).
- The “Charvakas Philosophical Tradition”, is largely a product of his thinking that prioritised empiricism and scepticism over Vedic ritualism.
- The original texts of the Charvakas have not survived, but references to their rationalist tradition are found in Buddhist and Jain works.
- The Buddha himself cautioned against accepting “what has been acquired by repeated hearing”, and encouraged independent study and thinking.
- Even within the wider Brahminical tradition, shades of opinion prevailed between the Brahmanas and the Shramanas, and active debate prevailed.
- Notably, even in Chhandogya Upanishad, one Uddalaka Aruni speaks of the importance observing the surrounding rather than being superstitious.
Modern Times:
- In the early modern period in Bengal, Raja Ram Mohan Roy and the Brahmo Samaj led the charge against regressive tradition.
- The regions of present day Maharashtra has a long history of radical thought that challenged several ideas embedded in the caste hierarchies.
- It was here that Babasaheb Ambedkar embraced Buddhism, and the Republican parties carry forward his legacy in their own ways.
- Jyotiba Phule and Savitri Phule rejected caste and gender inequalities.
- The first recorded reservation in educational institutes for backward castes was in Maharashtra by Chhatrapati Shahu Maharaj of Kolhapur (1894-1922).
- Narayana Guru in Kerala and E V Ramasamy (Periyar) in Tamil Nadu were early advocates of progress, and their ideas impacted politics deeply.
- The Self-Respect movement in Tamil Nadu and the Leftist movement in Kerala and West Bengal made a strong case for rationalism and egalitarianism.
What is the way ahead?
- Article 51A (H) of the Constitution of India gives a call “to develop the scientific temper, humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform”.
- The leaders of the national movement hoped that the lofty ideals of the emerging Indian state would encourage a modern and progressive outlook.
- Rationalism would also help in undoing the feudal setup that has been in place since long and put us strongly on a path towards social and economic equality.
- In this context, it is important for the state to ensure that vested interests don’t succeed in stifling the voices of progressivism.
Source: Indian Express
